Henry Fuseli, The Nightmare: a demon crouches on a sleeping woman's chest while a horse's head looks through the curtains

What Is Gothic Art? From Cathedrals to Dark Art Today

Search for "gothic art" and you'll find two quite different things. One is a style of medieval architecture and painting that began in France almost 900 years ago. The other is the dark, macabre art people mean when they talk about something looking "gothic" today: skulls, demons, haunted houses and religious imagery turned upside down. The two are connected, and the story of how one became the other runs through cathedrals, a famous novel, a few very disturbing paintings and a nightclub in Soho.

Where Gothic art began

Gothic architecture is usually traced back to the Abbey of Saint-Denis, just north of Paris. Abbot Suger, who led the abbey from 1122 to 1151, rebuilt its choir, which was consecrated on 11 June 1144. According to the Basilica of Saint-Denis, it brought together pointed arches, ribbed vaults and large stained glass windows that filled the building with light.

That combination spread across Europe over the following centuries. The pointed arch, the ribbed vault, the flying buttress and the rose window became the recognisable features of the style (Palomar College), and it can be seen in cathedrals such as Notre-Dame in Paris.

Why it's called "Gothic"

The people who built these churches never called them Gothic. The name was used as an insult by Italian Renaissance writers, who preferred the architecture of ancient Rome. Giorgio Vasari, in his Lives of the Artists (1550), blamed the style on the Goths and described it as built "after the manner of their barbarous nations" (Mental Floss). The insult stuck, and eventually it stopped being an insult at all.

Gargoyles and grotesques

Gargoyles are the part of Gothic art most people picture first. A true gargoyle has a job: it is a carved spout that throws rainwater clear of the walls. The famous creatures watching over Paris from Notre-Dame are mostly something else. Le Stryge, the horned figure resting its head in its hands, was sculpted during the 19th-century restoration of the cathedral under Eugène Viollet-le-Duc, and it isn't a gargoyle because it doesn't drain water (Friends of Notre-Dame de Paris). Decorative figures like this are usually called grotesques or chimeras.

Death in medieval art

Death was everywhere in late medieval art, and one of the best-known examples is Hans Holbein the Younger's Dance of Death, a series of small woodcuts showing Death as a skeleton among the living. The Metropolitan Museum of Art dates the series to about 1526, and the first book edition was printed in Lyon in 1538 (The History of Art). Skeletons, skulls and the idea that death comes for everyone are still at the centre of dark art today.

The Gothic revival and the first Gothic novel

In the 18th century, "Gothic" started to mean something new. Horace Walpole turned his house at Strawberry Hill in Twickenham into a fantasy of medieval arches and battlements, now described as "Britain's finest example of Georgian Gothic revival architecture" (Strawberry Hill House).

In 1764 Walpole published The Castle of Otranto, anonymously, presenting it as a medieval story he had found. When he admitted to writing it, the second edition of 1765 was titled The Castle of Otranto, a Gothic Story. The British Library calls it "the first gothic novel ever published" (British Library). From then on, Gothic meant castles, ghosts, curses and terror as much as it meant architecture.

Gothic nightmares: Fuseli and Goya

Henry Fuseli, The Nightmare: a demon crouches on a sleeping woman's chest while a horse's head looks through the curtains

Henry Fuseli, The Nightmare, exhibited 1782. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Painters picked up the same taste for the supernatural. Henry Fuseli's The Nightmare, exhibited in 1782, shows a demon sitting on the chest of a sleeping woman while a horse's head pushes through the curtains. In 2006 Tate Britain built a whole exhibition, Gothic Nightmares: Fuseli, Blake and the Romantic Imagination, around Fuseli, William Blake and the period's "taste for fantastic and supernatural themes" (Tate).

Francisco de Goya, Saturn Devouring His Son: a wild-eyed giant biting into a headless body against a black background

Francisco de Goya, Saturn Devouring His Son, from the Black Paintings. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Even darker are Francisco de Goya's Black Paintings. Goya bought a house outside Madrid, the Quinta del Sordo, in September 1819, and over the next few years painted 14 murals in oil straight onto its walls: witches, evil spirits and, most famously, Saturn Devouring His Son. They were finished by September 1823, transferred to canvas in 1873 and are now in the Museo del Prado (Web Gallery of Art). They were never meant to be seen by the public, which might be why they are still so unsettling 200 years later.

From Gothic to goth

The last step came from music. According to the Museum of Youth Culture, the goth scene developed out of post-punk in the late 1970s, and producer Martin Hannett described Joy Division's sound as "Gothic" in 1979. In July 1982 Olli Wisdom and his band Specimen opened the Batcave, a club night in Soho closely tied to the early goth scene (The Quietus). Goth borrowed the whole visual history above (black clothing, crosses, skulls, the night, the supernatural) and made it something you could wear.

Gothic art in my designs

That mix of religious imagery, death and the supernatural is what most of my Unusual Horror Originals are built on. They're my own designs, made with independent artists:

GoreChrist T-Shirt: black tee with white Unusual Horror logo on front and a skeletal Christ back print

Hallowed House T-Shirt: model in black tee with a white front print of the logo above a haunted house

The nuns in the Sisters series have their own story in The Sisters: Nuns in Horror, and the goat skulls and pentagrams are explained in Baphomet, Pentagrams and Satanic Symbols Explained. You can browse everything in the gothic t-shirts collection, or the Goth Gifts collection if you're buying for someone else.

Gothic art FAQs

What is gothic art?

Originally, the style of architecture, sculpture, stained glass and painting that began at the Abbey of Saint-Denis in France in the 1140s and spread across medieval Europe. Today the term is also used for dark, macabre art inspired by that history and by Gothic fiction.

Why is it called Gothic?

Italian Renaissance writers such as Giorgio Vasari used the name as an insult, blaming the style on the Goths. The name stuck long after the insult was forgotten.

What is the difference between a gargoyle and a grotesque?

A gargoyle is a carved water spout that carries rain away from a building. A grotesque, or chimera, is purely decorative. Many of Notre-Dame's best-known figures, including Le Stryge, are grotesques added in the 19th century.

Is gothic art the same as dark art?

Not exactly. Gothic art in the historical sense is medieval. "Dark art" usually means modern art built on death, horror and the occult, which borrows heavily from Gothic imagery, the Gothic novel and painters like Fuseli and Goya.

Sources